New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
-
- Posts: 2834
- Joined: 03 Nov 2020, 22:10
- Favourite book/series: The Five Find-outers, The Six Cousins
- Favourite character: Ern
- Location: Germany
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
While I detest changes to the original text in books I have no problem with graphic novels, which I consider an addition to the Blyton canon in the same way as films and TV series. Having said that, I am a 'fan of graphic novels so probably somewhat biased.
Society Member
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
I agree that the books should be left as they were written but, as others have said, I don’t think of a graphic novel as a rewrite of the original books. It's an adaptation to a different medium, just like movies or TV shows...IceMaiden wrote: ↑15 Feb 2022, 23:35 Urgh . Am I the only one who absolutely cannot stand seeing things, particularly and especially Enid Blyton's wonderful books, being "redone", "reimagined" and "reinvented" by somebody other than the original inventor? The books should be left exactly the way they were written by Enid end of.
Having said that, I think it's fair to dislike an adaptation if it modernizes too much the story so that it becomes too different from the source material. I have no idea if that's the case with this graphic novel, not having seen it...
----------------------------------
“I never had any friends later on like the ones I had when I was twelve. Jesus, does anyone?”
― Stephen King, The Body
“I never had any friends later on like the ones I had when I was twelve. Jesus, does anyone?”
― Stephen King, The Body
- IceMaiden
- Posts: 2300
- Joined: 07 Jan 2016, 18:49
- Favourite book/series: Too many to mention! All of them!
- Favourite character: George
- Location: North Wales
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
If that's true I don't agree with that either. I don't believe someone's work should be reinvented by other people. What's wrong with the original that another needs to reinvent it? If I'd written a book personally I'd be upset and feel quite insulted if some other person then came along and reinvented my story and characters!
I have no issue with simply making the books into a comic book style, just with retelling them. Which the website clearly states it does.
- Fiona1986
- Posts: 10546
- Joined: 01 Dec 2007, 15:35
- Favourite book/series: Five Go to Smuggler's Top
- Favourite character: Julian Kirrin
- Location: Dundee, Scotland
- Contact:
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
Well, Shakespeare's dead, so I don't think he's really that bothered.
In writing nothing is sacred, and it shouldn't be. I mean, think of all the retellings of classic fairy tales. Greek mythology. Stories of Roman gods. Just about everything written today is inspired by something else on at least some level.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, isn't it?
As for this comic you simply couldn't take the book exactly as it is and make it a comic. There's far too much dialogue, for one.
In writing nothing is sacred, and it shouldn't be. I mean, think of all the retellings of classic fairy tales. Greek mythology. Stories of Roman gods. Just about everything written today is inspired by something else on at least some level.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, isn't it?
As for this comic you simply couldn't take the book exactly as it is and make it a comic. There's far too much dialogue, for one.
"It's the ash! It's falling!" yelled Julian, almost startling Dick out of his wits...
"Listen to its terrible groans and creaks!" yelled Julian, almost beside himself with impatience.
World of Blyton Blog
Society Member
"Listen to its terrible groans and creaks!" yelled Julian, almost beside himself with impatience.
World of Blyton Blog
Society Member
- Anita Bensoussane
- Forum Administrator
- Posts: 26898
- Joined: 30 Jan 2005, 23:25
- Favourite book/series: Adventure series, Six Cousins books, Six Bad Boys
- Favourite character: Jack Trent, Fatty and Elizabeth Allen
- Location: UK
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
Popular stories have always been reinvented. The tales Fiona mentions were orignally passed down orally, so each retelling was different. Many of William Shakespeare's plays were themselves simply reworkings of older tales which had been related numerous times in numerous ways. Enid Blyton wrote her own versions of fairy tales and legends too, and she not only retold the stories of Brer Rabbit but made up new ones. The Land of Far-Beyond is based on John Bunyan's The Pilgrim's Progress, albeit loosely, and she also retold the Jean de Brunhoff tales about Babar the Elephant.
Adaptations and spin-offs don't bother me. I find it interesting to see different versions and it's natural for much-loved stories to inspire reworkings which look at things from a new angle or express them in another form. I've always liked the musical West Side Story and the TV show Little House on the Prairie, even though they stray far from Romeo and Juliet and Laura Ingalls Wilder's autobiographical books respectively.
I feel it's important that the author of the new material is genuinely inspired by a previous text though, rather than simply producing work to order (having been asked to do so by a publisher, for example) with no deep knowledge of or interest in the source material. Also, I think the original or definitive text should remain available. Picture-strip books and the like tend to be ephemeral anyway. What's worse is the constant updating which makes it look as though a particular book or series is still in print (e.g. the Famous Five series) but hides the fact that the text differs quite significantly from what the author wrote. In my opinion, the original or definitive texts should continue to be made available alongside any modernisations, adaptations and spin-offs.
Adaptations and spin-offs don't bother me. I find it interesting to see different versions and it's natural for much-loved stories to inspire reworkings which look at things from a new angle or express them in another form. I've always liked the musical West Side Story and the TV show Little House on the Prairie, even though they stray far from Romeo and Juliet and Laura Ingalls Wilder's autobiographical books respectively.
I feel it's important that the author of the new material is genuinely inspired by a previous text though, rather than simply producing work to order (having been asked to do so by a publisher, for example) with no deep knowledge of or interest in the source material. Also, I think the original or definitive text should remain available. Picture-strip books and the like tend to be ephemeral anyway. What's worse is the constant updating which makes it look as though a particular book or series is still in print (e.g. the Famous Five series) but hides the fact that the text differs quite significantly from what the author wrote. In my opinion, the original or definitive texts should continue to be made available alongside any modernisations, adaptations and spin-offs.
"Heyho for a starry night and a heathery bed!" - Jack, The Secret Island.
"There is no bond like the bond of having read and liked the same books."
- E. Nesbit, The Wonderful Garden.
Society Member
"There is no bond like the bond of having read and liked the same books."
- E. Nesbit, The Wonderful Garden.
Society Member
- IceMaiden
- Posts: 2300
- Joined: 07 Jan 2016, 18:49
- Favourite book/series: Too many to mention! All of them!
- Favourite character: George
- Location: North Wales
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
I don't personally think being dead should give others a free pass to your work but that's just me.Fiona1986 wrote: ↑02 Mar 2022, 00:24 Well, Shakespeare's dead, so I don't think he's really that bothered.
In writing nothing is sacred, and it shouldn't be. I mean, think of all the retellings of classic fairy tales. Greek mythology. Stories of Roman gods. Just about everything written today is inspired by something else on at least some level.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, isn't it?
As for this comic you simply couldn't take the book exactly as it is and make it a comic. There's far too much dialogue, for one.
My main issue with retelling EB books, apart from simply plain disagreeing with it, is that almost guaranteed the writing won't be what Enid actually wrote. That's the bit that grates. It's not really flattery if someone alters your work is it.
- pete9012S
- Posts: 17649
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 15:32
- Favourite book/series: Five On A Treasure Island
- Favourite character: Frederick Algernon Trotteville
- Location: UK
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
I understand your points IceMaiden. I agree with you too.
However, I don't know how you feel about the annuals.
I received the very first 1970's one in 1977.
I hadn't yet read Hike in book form and the 1970's tv show hadn't yet come out.
I can't tell you how much I enjoyed this annual.
I hadn't read the story. It was all fresh and new and exciting.
https://www.enidblytonsociety.co.uk/boo ... e+Together
The 1977 annual (above) follows the story quite well and is miles closer to the book than this later 1985 magazine:
https://www.enidblytonsociety.co.uk/bly ... perid=4330
However, I don't know how you feel about the annuals.
I received the very first 1970's one in 1977.
I hadn't yet read Hike in book form and the 1970's tv show hadn't yet come out.
I can't tell you how much I enjoyed this annual.
I hadn't read the story. It was all fresh and new and exciting.
https://www.enidblytonsociety.co.uk/boo ... e+Together
The 1977 annual (above) follows the story quite well and is miles closer to the book than this later 1985 magazine:
https://www.enidblytonsociety.co.uk/bly ... perid=4330
" A kind heart always brings its own reward," said Mrs. Lee.
- The Christmas Tree Aeroplane -
Society Member
- The Christmas Tree Aeroplane -
Society Member
-
- Posts: 6386
- Joined: 26 Dec 2004, 12:20
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
https://www.enidblytonsociety.co.uk/boo ... ure+Island
One done this morning, I will do the other one soon.
One done this morning, I will do the other one soon.
- pete9012S
- Posts: 17649
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 15:32
- Favourite book/series: Five On A Treasure Island
- Favourite character: Frederick Algernon Trotteville
- Location: UK
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
Marvelous work Tony - Many thanks.
" A kind heart always brings its own reward," said Mrs. Lee.
- The Christmas Tree Aeroplane -
Society Member
- The Christmas Tree Aeroplane -
Society Member
- Anita Bensoussane
- Forum Administrator
- Posts: 26898
- Joined: 30 Jan 2005, 23:25
- Favourite book/series: Adventure series, Six Cousins books, Six Bad Boys
- Favourite character: Jack Trent, Fatty and Elizabeth Allen
- Location: UK
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
Picture-strip books like these are just playful tributes and tend to be ephemeral but it's good to have everything in the Cave so thanks for doing that, Tony!
"Heyho for a starry night and a heathery bed!" - Jack, The Secret Island.
"There is no bond like the bond of having read and liked the same books."
- E. Nesbit, The Wonderful Garden.
Society Member
"There is no bond like the bond of having read and liked the same books."
- E. Nesbit, The Wonderful Garden.
Society Member
-
- Posts: 2834
- Joined: 03 Nov 2020, 22:10
- Favourite book/series: The Five Find-outers, The Six Cousins
- Favourite character: Ern
- Location: Germany
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
Excellent Tony, many thanks! As a graphic novel 'fan I might even consider investing in a copy.
Society Member
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
What bothers me about this new version is that the cover picture children are too old. They all look to be 16+ IMO.
DSR
- Wolfgang
- Posts: 3139
- Joined: 06 Apr 2008, 05:26
- Favourite book/series: The children at Green Meadows/Adventure-series
- Favourite character: Fatty
- Location: Germany
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
In German 6 books are available so far.
Success is 10% inspiration and 90% perspiration.
- Jomo
- Posts: 368
- Joined: 02 Jan 2022, 07:44
- Favourite book/series: Famous Five
- Favourite character: George, Timmy, Anne
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
Re: New Famous Five Graphic Novel - Feb 2022
Agreed!
This would have been a great opportunity to let them age naturally - at the calculated rate of one Earth Age Year for every Blytonian Year of 4.2 Earth Years.
You do the maths. Clearly, Enid was a Time Lord.
- BTW, at that rate they would now be about 30 years old.
10,11,12 years old in 1942
2022 - 1962 = 80
80 / 4.2 = 19
29, 30, 31 years old in 2022
And I am 18.4 Blytonian years old now. Feels just about right
“To grow up in intimate association with nature – animal and vegetable – is an irreplaceable form of wealth and culture.”
~Miles Franklin, Childhood At Brindabella: My First Ten Years
~Miles Franklin, Childhood At Brindabella: My First Ten Years