Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
- Uncle Alister
- Posts: 71
- Joined: 12 Mar 2011, 17:11
- Favourite book/series: Five Get Into Trouble
- Favourite character: Fatty
- Location: Scotland
Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Sorry if this has been covered before. But I cannot find anything about it.
Am I correct in thinking that:
1. Uncle Quentin is Julian, Dick and Anne's father's brother?
2. Julian, Dick, Anne and George's surname is Kirrin?
If so, how come Aunt Fanny appears to be descended from the family that once owned all the land around 'Kirrin' Cottage as well as 'Kirrin' island?
Are Aunt Fanny and Julian, Dick and Anne's mother 'sisters', and did Uncle Quentin and his brother - Julian, Dick and Anne's father - marry one each, then change their surname from whatever it was to 'Kirrin'? After all, if women can change their surnames to those of their husbands, why shouldn't it work the other way round - especially if the women concerned are more able to 'provide' than their husbands?
In the first Famous Five book we are told that Uncle Quentin doesn't earn much from his academic work. So we can only presume that he was being supported mainly by his wife.
Can you understand why I am a little confused?
Am I correct in thinking that:
1. Uncle Quentin is Julian, Dick and Anne's father's brother?
2. Julian, Dick, Anne and George's surname is Kirrin?
If so, how come Aunt Fanny appears to be descended from the family that once owned all the land around 'Kirrin' Cottage as well as 'Kirrin' island?
Are Aunt Fanny and Julian, Dick and Anne's mother 'sisters', and did Uncle Quentin and his brother - Julian, Dick and Anne's father - marry one each, then change their surname from whatever it was to 'Kirrin'? After all, if women can change their surnames to those of their husbands, why shouldn't it work the other way round - especially if the women concerned are more able to 'provide' than their husbands?
In the first Famous Five book we are told that Uncle Quentin doesn't earn much from his academic work. So we can only presume that he was being supported mainly by his wife.
Can you understand why I am a little confused?
'Woof!' said Timmy, and wagged his tail.
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Correctunclealister wrote: Am I correct in thinking that:
1. Uncle Quentin is Julian, Dick and Anne's father's brother?
Correct2. Julian, Dick, Anne and George's surname is Kirrin?
Your confusion is quite understandable. By some incredible coincidence, both Quentin and Fanny shared the same surname prior to their marriage. (I think ) This has been the subject of much debate on these forums in the past. It could well be that Kirrin was a very common surname in that part of the country. Enid Blyton never really went into fine detail, much was left for the reader to decide!
- Fiona1986
- Posts: 10545
- Joined: 01 Dec 2007, 15:35
- Favourite book/series: Five Go to Smuggler's Top
- Favourite character: Julian Kirrin
- Location: Dundee, Scotland
- Contact:
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
And let's not start wondering where Barnard came from
"It's the ash! It's falling!" yelled Julian, almost startling Dick out of his wits...
"Listen to its terrible groans and creaks!" yelled Julian, almost beside himself with impatience.
World of Blyton Blog
Society Member
"Listen to its terrible groans and creaks!" yelled Julian, almost beside himself with impatience.
World of Blyton Blog
Society Member
- Pippa-Stef
- Posts: 4322
- Joined: 23 Feb 2008, 14:32
- Favourite book/series: Famous Five/ Malory Towers
- Favourite character: Julian/ Bill Robinson/ Sally Hope
- Location: Woodley, Berkshire
- Contact:
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Fiona1986 wrote:And let's not start wondering where Barnard came from
Well it comes and goes so quickly... It could be because Julian, Dick and Anne's mother remarried, so she's Mrs Barnard and the children stay as Kirrins which could account for Julian introducing them as the Kirrins on arrival at Maga Glen?
"You're so sharp you'll cut yourself one day!" Hunchy said going to the door
"So my Mother told me that when I was two years old!" said Julian and the others giggled.
http://worldofblyton.wordpress.com/
"So my Mother told me that when I was two years old!" said Julian and the others giggled.
http://worldofblyton.wordpress.com/
-
- Posts: 453
- Joined: 13 Aug 2011, 05:53
- Favourite book/series: Malory Towers, Famous Five, Adventure series
- Favourite character: George Kirrin, Darrell Rivers, Bets Hilton
- Location: USA
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
I always presumed Quentin and Fanny came from the same area and coincidentally had the same last names before they got married. There's the village of Kirrin, Kirrin Cottage, Kirrin Island, Kirrin Castle, Kirrin Bay ... it makes sense to me that there'd be lots of people with the last name of Kirrin who are probably are very distantly related.
"Lucy, you want more backbone -– you've got your wishbone where your backbone ought to be!" -- "House-at-the-Corner"
-
- Posts: 65
- Joined: 08 Jul 2011, 10:03
- Favourite book/series: Adventure series Secret series, Family books, FFOs
- Favourite character: Fatty, Jack Trent and moonface
- Location: Mysore, India
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
I guess Quentin and Fanny did have the same surnames before they got married. It was the only conclusion I come to after reading the books. I guess this might be off-topic but I wonder why Quentin got married in the first place?
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
I imagine Quentin and Fanny to be cousins, Barnard was a complete mess-up by Enid Blyton.
Society Member
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
I can only assume that he needed someone to run a house for him!centcat wrote:I guess this might be off-topic but I wonder why Quentin got married in the first place?
Society Member
-
- Posts: 2996
- Joined: 29 Nov 2007, 19:12
- Favourite book/series: St Clare's/FFO's.
- Favourite character: Fatty/Claudine
- Location: UK, the cold part of
- Contact:
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Let's be honest - it was most likely a mistake on Blyton's part.. the books are littered with them
As to why Quentin got married .. yeah, prolly just wanted someone to look after him. Maybe he could not afford a housekeeper or something!
He was obviously so busy that they only got around to producing one child tho
As to why Quentin got married .. yeah, prolly just wanted someone to look after him. Maybe he could not afford a housekeeper or something!
He was obviously so busy that they only got around to producing one child tho
http://europeforum.freeforums.net" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
- Uncle Alister
- Posts: 71
- Joined: 12 Mar 2011, 17:11
- Favourite book/series: Five Get Into Trouble
- Favourite character: Fatty
- Location: Scotland
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
I'm inclined to agree with you.Yak wrote:Let's be honest - it was most likely a mistake on Blyton's part..
Very possibly. However, I would like to think that Uncle Quentin mainly married Aunt Fanny because he was in love with her, wanted to spend the rest of his life with her and have a family. Maybe George was an only child because her mother had a troublesome pregnancy and birth and was advised against trying for another baby.Yak wrote:As to why Quentin got married .. yeah, prolly just wanted someone to look after him. Maybe he could not afford a housekeeper or something!
'Woof!' said Timmy, and wagged his tail.
-
- Posts: 2996
- Joined: 29 Nov 2007, 19:12
- Favourite book/series: St Clare's/FFO's.
- Favourite character: Fatty/Claudine
- Location: UK, the cold part of
- Contact:
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Or maybe she looked at George and thought - ooh no! Never again!
http://europeforum.freeforums.net" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
- Pippa-Stef
- Posts: 4322
- Joined: 23 Feb 2008, 14:32
- Favourite book/series: Famous Five/ Malory Towers
- Favourite character: Julian/ Bill Robinson/ Sally Hope
- Location: Woodley, Berkshire
- Contact:
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Oh the joys of active imaginations and no one to provide a JK Rowling type experience to fill the gaps in for us!
"You're so sharp you'll cut yourself one day!" Hunchy said going to the door
"So my Mother told me that when I was two years old!" said Julian and the others giggled.
http://worldofblyton.wordpress.com/
"So my Mother told me that when I was two years old!" said Julian and the others giggled.
http://worldofblyton.wordpress.com/
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
I don't really think he married her just to run the house, he appears to be fond of her. I'd guess that George was an only child because I can't imagine Quentin wanting another noisy baby in the house!
It's interesting that Enid comes in for criticism for inconsistencies in her books, as she's not alone. I've just finished reading Agatha Christie's The ABC Murders. In one part they visit a family in a bungalow and then go upstairs to look at the bedroom. My understanding of a bungalow is a house with only ground floor accommodation. Also early in the book a character refers to reading The Railway Children. Later Poirot 'discovers' the book in the house and uses it as evidence against the reader, strange as he'd already admitted he'd been reading the book.
It's interesting that Enid comes in for criticism for inconsistencies in her books, as she's not alone. I've just finished reading Agatha Christie's The ABC Murders. In one part they visit a family in a bungalow and then go upstairs to look at the bedroom. My understanding of a bungalow is a house with only ground floor accommodation. Also early in the book a character refers to reading The Railway Children. Later Poirot 'discovers' the book in the house and uses it as evidence against the reader, strange as he'd already admitted he'd been reading the book.
Society Member
- Oscar Spain
- Posts: 126
- Joined: 18 Oct 2005, 09:21
- Favourite book/series: Famous Five
- Favourite character: Julian (F.F.)
- Location: Madrid (Spain)
- Contact:
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
My parents are cousins and I share the last name too... In small towns, some inbreeding is common ...
Oscar P.
Film director / Writer / Medical Student
http://www.delcinealhospital.com" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Film director / Writer / Medical Student
http://www.delcinealhospital.com" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Re: Uncle Quentin & Aunt Fanny?
Although I've read the book a million times, I've never spotted that!Of course, it might've been a bungalow with a loft conversion/dormer window. No idea on the Railway Children faux pas though.Katharine wrote:I've just finished reading Agatha Christie's The ABC Murders. In one part they visit a family in a bungalow and then go upstairs to look at the bedroom. My understanding of a bungalow is a house with only ground floor accommodation.
Society Member