Which book do you prefer?

Daisy · Post by **Daisy** » 22 Jul 2014, 09:40

The Sea of Adventure
or
Five on Kirrin island Again?

Farwa · Post by **Farwa** » 22 Jul 2014, 09:41

Five on Kirrin island Again

Five on Kirrin island Again
OR
Five Go On a Hike Together?

Dinah Cunningham · Post by **Dinah Cunningham** » 22 Jul 2014, 10:49

Five on Kirrin Island again
or
The Secret Island?

(I was wondering if it would be interesting to write why the book was chosen?)

Daisy · Post by **Daisy** » 22 Jul 2014, 11:38

Dinah Cunningham wrote: (I was wondering if it would be interesting to write why the book was chosen?)

People have done so from time to time and yes, I agree it would make this more interesting.

Lucky Star · Post by **Lucky Star** » 22 Jul 2014, 11:46

The Secret Island or The Valley of Adventure?

I chose Island because it is so unique in the Blyton canon whereas the sixth FF book is merely a good read.

Dinah Cunningham · Post by **Dinah Cunningham** » 22 Jul 2014, 14:08

The Valley of Adventure
or
Five run away together?

I found it very difficult to decide, as I really like Island but I like the Adventure-Kids more and I like the Valley and their farn-cave.

Daisy · Post by **Daisy** » 22 Jul 2014, 14:24

I think Valley would just win my vote as it is more exciting and dangerous - both books feature a cave where the children "live" for a while though, which is interesting. I hadn't thought of that similarity before.
So-
Valley of Adventure
or
Five go to Smugglers' Top?

Deej · Post by **Deej** » 22 Jul 2014, 21:43

Five go to Smugglers' Top
or
Five Go Down to the Sea?

Courtenay · Post by **Courtenay** » 22 Jul 2014, 21:50

Five Go Down to the Sea
or
Five Go Off to Camp?

Daisy · Post by **Daisy** » 22 Jul 2014, 22:41

I prefer Five go off to Camp as it has an unusual setting and a very exciting and at times quite scary story. At least it was scary when I read it as an 11 year old.

Five go off to Camp
or
Five Fall into Adventure?

Dinah Cunningham · Post by **Dinah Cunningham** » 23 Jul 2014, 07:56

None of the two are my favourites, but I think Fall wins, only because Jo is such an interesting character.

Five fall into Adventure
or
The Castle of Adventure?

Lucky Star · Post by **Lucky Star** » 23 Jul 2014, 18:37

Castle because I love its dark brooding atmosphere and thrilling plot.

The Castle of Adventure vs The Six Bad Boys.

Daisy · Post by **Daisy** » 23 Jul 2014, 18:44

Oh goodness me - what a contrast. On the whole, I think I'd have to choose Six Bad Boys. It is unique rather than one of a series, and the subject is dealt with very well.

Six Bad Boys
or
The Family at Redroofs

Lucky Star · Post by **Lucky Star** » 23 Jul 2014, 18:52

Sorry for the contrast. It just jumped into my head.

I'll go for Six Bad Boys again as it's the only one of the two that I have read.

The Six Bad Boys or The Treasure Hunters?

Daisy · Post by **Daisy** » 23 Jul 2014, 19:53

Don't apologise.... It makes it more interesting if the books are not too similar. Again you make another good suggestion.. those 2 books are both so good and completely different. I'll go for The Treasure Hunters this time. A nice story.
The Treasure Hunters
or
The House-at-the-Corner?

Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?

Re: Which book do you prefer?