Page 3 of 3

Re: R. J. McGregor - The Young Detectives, etc.

Posted: 09 Sep 2017, 12:47
by pete9012S
I've now read the first four chapters of the book and I'm enjoying it.
It's hard to believe this book was written long before Enid Blyton's adventure novels.

The author incorporates a good vocabulary that would stretch and increase the word power of any young readers who took the time to look up words they were unfamiliar with and the writer incorporates them in an amusing easy fashion.

The books setting is fabulous.The sort of place you would want to spend a long summer holiday. The children yearn for an adventure,but some of them don't think that they could realistically hope to have one - some do.

If you decide to read the book,be sure to mentally compare the food descriptions written by this author's to Enid Blyton's.

I'm enjoying the book so far.It's well written and the children's mother comes across as a rather cool,forward thinking lady indeed.

I always enjoy checking up any of the background references in the books I'm reading. A reference to a book their father was reading called 'Christopher Strong' on page 48 of this book proved most interesting..

Re: R. J. McGregor - The Young Detectives, etc.

Posted: 09 Sep 2017, 12:52
by Courtenay
Sounds good, Pete! Very promising so far. I'll be interested to hear if the mystery/adventure itself is up to anything like Enid's standard, if you can tell us (without spoilers) once you know... :wink:

Re: R. J. McGregor - The Young Detectives, etc.

Posted: 09 Sep 2017, 13:01
by pete9012S
Here's a short sample of a handful of pages from the start of the book:

The Young Detectives - R.J. McGregor 1934 (sample)

http://imgur.com/a/mzhkf" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Re: R. J. McGregor - The Young Detectives, etc.

Posted: 09 Sep 2017, 15:38
by Courtenay
Wow, even after only a few pages I really like it! :D I think this one will have to go on my to-read list as well. Thanks, Pete.

Re: R. J. McGregor - The Young Detectives, etc.

Posted: 25 Sep 2017, 22:33
by Tony Summerfield
For those who have been following the books of R.J. McGregor I now only have a few pages to go to finish The Young Detectives so I have fished out the other two books by him (looking inside I see that they cost me 5p each!!). The Secret of Deadman's Cove written three years later in 1937 is another story about the Mackie Family and I will be starting that tonight. However the third book which wasn't written until 1957, The Secret of Smugglers' Wood is about a completely different family.

Re: R. J. McGregor - The Young Detectives, etc.

Posted: 25 Sep 2017, 23:39
by pete9012S
Yes,I'm 75% through the book myself. I'm saving the last bit to read on holiday this Saturday. The children's mother has a lot more involvement in this adventure than any Enid Blyton book I can recall.

The aunty who comes to stay is very lightly sketched in too.Well she is at the stage of the book I'm at - she make make a last chapter resurgence!